By definition, there is no need for leaseholders to prove any mismanagement by a landlord. The right to manage is available to leaseholders, whether the landlord’s chosen management has been good, bad or indifferent.
But being realistic, the main reason for leaseholders to replace their management company is because they are not satisfied with the current management situation. In many cases there is a background of poor management or service charge complaints, and so the Right To Manage procedure can be adversarial.
Often freeholders have a vested interest in retaining the current management situation, and are reluctant to see any possible revenue streams disappear. In cases like these, a freeholder may seek to disallow an RTM claim that you may make. Frequently a freeholder will pass a new Claim to their chosen solicitors to carefully examine the procedure to look for a reason to reject the claim.
Therefore it is vital not to overlook any aspect of the Claim process. Even though the process is reasonable well defined, there are still many avenues to reject a Claim. Many disputed cases end up being decided by the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal (LVT). Several of these rejection reasons include:
1. The Claim Notice not given to the landlord of the whole or part of the premises (LVT rejection of Claim 26th January 2009)
2. Less than two thirds of the flats being held by qualifying tenants (rejection of Claim 17th April 2009)
3. Having less than 50% of owners being members of the RTM company (rejection of Claim 8th September 2008)
4. Not actually keeping the member’s register correctly updated at the correct location
5. Insufficient documents to prove the members are actually qualifying tenants (rejection of Claim 6th May 2008)
6. Any incorrect company formation – not limited by guarantee, incorrect Memorandum of Association, no incorporation certificate (rejection of Claim 1st May 2009 – second attempt)
7. More than 25% commercial space in the building (anything near this figure is likely to be disputed and require detailed surveyor proof)
8. A date for a Counter Notice being too close (rejection of Claim 9th May 2008)
9. Some or all non-participants not being served the correctly worded invitation to join (rejection of Claim 22nd February 2008)
10. Non-participants not having access to the required company documentation
11. Non-participants not receiving enough time to respond
12. Insufficient proof of RTM members receiving copies of the Claim (rejection of Claim 6th May 2008)
As well as these, there are other, admittedly less common issues with RTM Claims. Clearly, it is vital to follow the process exactly, to try and avoid a counter Claim rejecting your application.
But don’t let the cautious tone of this article stop you from replacing poor management. The good news is that if you do things exactly right, your RTM takeover is only a matter of a few months away.

