If Crucifixion Was So Awful, Why Not Rescue Jesus Before He Died?

When an accident happens, we show we value human life in the attempt to rescue someone from danger or death. If this is universal, why doesn’t it apply to Jesus? And if it was impossible for his beleaguered disciples to make a successful rescue bid, seeing that Peter’s bold strike at Jesus’ arrest had failed, (see John 18:10-11) maybe after all, God would step in to rescue Jesus and restore his honour.

FALSE OPTIMISM DASHED

Perhaps one or two of the more optimistic disciples nursed this hope as they watched Jesus hang on the cross. Mind you, if any group of people could have conjured up some kind of scheme that saw someone else die in Jesus’ place, they would have grabbed at it! Because they really did want Jesus to be their Messianic warrior hero and king! But the stark reality of death is too well known, and the possibility of mistaken identity in such a high profile public execution, is so far from all the evidence, that the thought of Jesus escaping death, was a ploy of last resort dreamed up by his enemies as a counter explanation for Jesus’ resurrection.

We also need to face Jesus’ direct teaching to his disciples. From the time Peter affirmed Jesus as the Messiah, ‘Jesus began to show his disciples that he must go to Jerusalem and suffer many things from the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be killed, and on the third day be raised’ (Matthew 16:21). It was then that Peter tried to deflect Jesus from the pathway to the cross, and had received the stern rebuke, ‘Get behind me, Satan! You are a hindrance to me. For you are not setting your mind on the things of God, but on the things of man’ (Matthew 16:23).

THE EXPECTED AND THE UNEXPECTED

The witness of the Gospels is so uniformly clear that Jesus Messiah knew he must die willingly in obedience to God’s will, that to have that purpose suddenly reversed, strikes a terrible uncertainty into the heart of what is most certain – the faithfulness of God. And if there is one thing that God is not, it is fickle and moody – these traits come from fallen creatures, not the perfect, eternally unchanging Almighty God. And if someone else had died in Jesus’ place, he who professes to be the Truth itself, (John 14:6) did not carry out what he said he would – go to his death, and has lost all credibility.

Jesus described the sort of thinking that wished to see him preserved from death as coming from fallen human nature. So, of course, it is completely understandable that Jesus’ disciples would try to preserve him from death. And, as subsequent history shows, Jesus’ disciples weren’t the last to wish that he might be spared from death! Other ideas have since appeared that would cloud the clear statements of New Testament Scripture.

Indeed, such was the degree of later confusion about Jesus Messiah, that early Church Councils were called to deal with several other errors about his person, (including Arianism and Nestorianism). Both were serious errors, the first of which denied the essential deity of Jesus Messiah in his Incarnation. The first Council of Nicea met in 325 to deal with the controversy aroused by Arianism, and confirmed the biblical position of the full deity of Jesus Messiah. Nestorianism held a confused view – both to Messiah’s dual nature and dual persons, rather than two natures in one Person, truly human and fully divine, the position clarified by the Council of Ephesus in 431.

In spite of Nestorius’ views being condemned, he continued to attract a large following, which eventually resulted in an eastward spread with churches holding his beliefs established in the middle east and even China. This early eastward flow of unorthodox Christian beliefs, goes some way to explain how strange views of Jesus’ death became widespread over many lands.

GOD’S WAYS HIGHER THAN OURS

Of course, on one level, it is perfectly understandable that those who saw things from a normal human viewpoint would try fervently to prevent Jesus from going to the cross to die. But, the case for Jesus to be rescued from the cross before his death depends on a very different way of understanding Jesus’ mission compared with his own teaching. In that, Jesus’ used words to describe how he, ‘the good shepherd’ was the one who, ‘lays down his life for the sheep’ (John 10:11).

In terms of his own goal, the reason Jesus did not flinch in the face of death was that he had come to rescue those who were defenceless and unable to save themselves. And he did this by giving his life as the once-for-all sacrifice for sin, to rescue from eternal death all those would turn to him as the Saviour bearing their sins upon the cross. Here is love beyond measure. That is one huge reason for Jesus not to be rescued from the cross.

Michael J. S. Austin, PhD

Comments are closed.

Freelance Web Designer | WordPress Developer | Hong Kong